| Rank | Butts | Total |
| 1 | Big Dick’s BBQ | 16.1250 |
| 2 | Buckwheat’s BBQ | 16.0700 |
| 3 | Smokin’ Stacks | 16.0688 |
| 4 | Pimp My Pig | 15.7838 |
| 5 | All Smoked Up | 15.7075 |
| 6 | Doko Smoke | 15.5963 |
| 7 | Carter-Que-Ing | 15.5513 |
| 8 | Backwoods Bar B Que | 15.5250 |
| 9 | S’Lowcountry Q | 15.4567 |
| 10 | JT’s BBQ | 15.3738 |
| 11 | No Pig Left Behind | 15.2738 |
| 12 | Sweetdaddy’s Smokehouse | 15.0863 |
| 13 | Potbelly Cookers | 14.8100 |
| 14 | Qued UP | 14.3413 |
| 15 | Hog Wild BBQ | 13.8388 |
| 16 | A+ Butts | 13.4433 |
| 17 | Pig Envy | 13.3300 |
| Butts | Appearance | Aroma | Texture / Tenderness | Taste | Overall Impression |
| Big Dick’s BBQ | 2.8500 | 1.9000 | 4.7667 | 4.7333 | 1.8750 |
| Buckwheat’s BBQ | 2.8400 | 1.8725 | 4.7425 | 4.7688 | 1.8463 |
| Smokin’ Stacks | 2.8713 | 1.8663 | 4.7313 | 4.7688 | 1.8313 |
| Pimp My Pig | 2.8338 | 1.7938 | 4.7000 | 4.6625 | 1.7938 |
| All Smoked Up | 2.8713 | 1.8188 | 4.6438 | 4.6063 | 1.7675 |
| Doko Smoke | 2.8000 | 1.8375 | 4.5625 | 4.6125 | 1.7838 |
| Carter-Que-Ing | 2.7500 | 1.7813 | 4.6125 | 4.6438 | 1.7638 |
| Backwoods Bar B Que | 2.8750 | 1.8000 | 4.4875 | 4.5750 | 1.7875 |
| S’Lowcountry Q | 2.7833 | 1.8000 | 4.6000 | 4.5000 | 1.7733 |
| JT’s BBQ | 2.7625 | 1.7750 | 4.5000 | 4.5500 | 1.7863 |
| No Pig Left Behind | 2.6738 | 1.7625 | 4.5313 | 4.5850 | 1.7213 |
| Sweetdaddy’s Smokehouse | 2.7125 | 1.7375 | 4.4625 | 4.4375 | 1.7363 |
| Potbelly Cookers | 2.6000 | 1.7333 | 4.4167 | 4.3667 | 1.6933 |
| Qued UP | 2.5125 | 1.6250 | 4.3375 | 4.2375 | 1.6288 |
| Hog Wild BBQ | 2.3375 | 1.5750 | 4.2250 | 4.1875 | 1.5138 |
| A+ Butts | 2.4000 | 1.5667 | 4.0500 | 3.9500 | 1.4767 |
| Pig Envy | 2.1667 | 1.4333 | 4.2500 | 3.9833 | 1.4967 |