| Rank | Butts | Total |
| 1 | JT’s BBQ | 15.5500 |
| 2 | Ledyard Bar B Que.Co | 15.4020 |
| 3 | Can’t Qiut Smokin’ | 15.3200 |
| 4 | Blind Swine BBQ | 15.0200 |
| 5 | Slap Yo Moma BBQ | 14.6800 |
| 6 | Holy Smoke’s | 14.5583 |
| 7 | Team Heybo | 14.5050 |
| 8 | The Grilling Tigers | 14.2940 |
| 9 | Heavenly Hog | 14.0833 |
| 10 | Just Having Fun | 13.9780 |
| 11 | Roadkill Cookers | 13.9420 |
| 12 | Palmetto Smoke House | DQ |
| Butts | Appearance | Aroma | Texture / Tenderness | Taste | Overall Impression |
| JT’s BBQ | 2.7417 | 1.7083 | 4.6500 | 4.6417 | 1.8083 |
| Ledyard Bar B Que.Co | 2.6600 | 1.9000 | 4.5200 | 4.5600 | 1.7620 |
| Can’t Qiut Smokin’ | 2.8200 | 1.8000 | 4.5200 | 4.4800 | 1.7000 |
| Blind Swine BBQ | 2.6200 | 1.6600 | 4.5200 | 4.5200 | 1.7000 |
| Slap Yo Moma BBQ | 2.6200 | 1.6400 | 4.4200 | 4.3600 | 1.6400 |
| Holy Smoke’s | 2.5417 | 1.6000 | 4.3667 | 4.4000 | 1.6500 |
| Team Heybo | 2.4917 | 1.6333 | 4.4500 | 4.3167 | 1.6133 |
| The Grilling Tigers | 2.5700 | 1.8400 | 4.1000 | 4.1300 | 1.6540 |
| Heavenly Hog | 2.4833 | 1.5667 | 4.2500 | 4.2333 | 1.5500 |
| Just Having Fun | 2.3200 | 1.6600 | 4.2300 | 4.1700 | 1.5980 |
| Roadkill Cookers | 2.2500 | 1.7500 | 4.1500 | 4.2100 | 1.5820 |
| Palmetto Smoke House | DQ | DQ | DQ | DQ | DQ |