| Butts | TOTAL | appearance | aroma | tenderness | taste | overall |
| All Smoked Up Gary Taylor | 16.15714 | 2.928571 | 1.771429 | 4.771429 | 4.828571 | 1.857143 |
| CBF Que Jeff Lee | 16.01429 | 2.828571 | 1.757143 | 4.8 | 4.8 | 1.828571 |
| Casual Smokers Jamie Mintz | 15.71429 | 2.757143 | 1.742857 | 4.728571 | 4.7 | 1.785714 |
| The Sauce and All That Goes With It Marty Almond | 15.6 | 2.714286 | 1.714286 | 4.7 | 4.685714 | 1.785714 |
| BB’s BBQ LLC Matt Bradberry | 15.4 | 2.614286 | 1.714286 | 4.685714 | 4.642857 | 1.742857 |
| Happy Grillmore Scott Walker | 14.81429 | 2.485714 | 1.614286 | 4.571429 | 4.5 | 1.642857 |
| Triple H Lake Wylie David Pinit | 14.47143 | 2.485714 | 1.657143 | 4.371429 | 4.342857 | 1.614286 |
| Ribs | TOTAL | appearance | aroma | tenderness | taste | overall |
| All Smoked Up | 16.01429 | 2.8 | 1.814286 | 4.728571 | 4.828571 | 1.842857 |
| CBF Que | 15.98571 | 2.771429 | 1.771429 | 4.771429 | 4.814286 | 1.857143 |
| Casual Smokers | 15.88571 | 2.8 | 1.771429 | 4.7 | 4.8 | 1.814286 |
| The Sauce and All That Goes With It | 15.48571 | 2.728571 | 1.742857 | 4.6 | 4.657143 | 1.757143 |
| BB’s BBQ LLC | 15.11429 | 2.542857 | 1.7 | 4.542857 | 4.657143 | 1.671429 |
| Happy Grillmore | 14.97143 | 2.571429 | 1.671429 | 4.571429 | 4.542857 | 1.614286 |